For 65 Carey Cir, a 3-bed, 1-bath, 830 sqft single-family home in Stoughton, rent comps for similar houses point to a solid monthly range of $3,300–$3,975. With annual gross income potential between $40K and $48K, the estimated payback period (ignoring expenses/taxes) is roughly 10–12 years at current valuation. Stoughton is a hot seller’s market with low inventory and rising prices[1], which boosts rental demand and supports higher rent ceilings. The property is compact for a 3-bed, but walkable to top-rated schools and nestled in a stable, desirable neighborhood. Limited size and only one bath are minor drawbacks, but the lot size and classic ranch style are attractive for families.

To maximize value, consider modernizing the kitchen and bath—these upgrades routinely deliver outsized rent bumps in Stoughton’s family-focused market. Adding in-unit laundry or central air could also push rents toward the high end of the range. If selling is on the table, list soon: seller competition is low, and buyers are paying over ask. Staging the home to highlight its proximity to schools and the large lot will draw both renters and buyers.