The Flip Potential of
25 W 1st St Everett, PA 15537 is medium.

25 W 1st St in Everett is a classic "heavy rehab" flip. At ~1.7K sqft, 4 beds, 2 baths on a big 0.57-acre lot, it’s a solid size for the area. But it needs major systems: furnace, plumbing, electrical, plus finishing a gutted bath and likely cosmetic updates throughout. Comps on nearby 4-bed homes cluster roughly in the mid–100Ks to low–200Ks once fixed up, so there’s upside—but only if you buy it right and keep the rehab tight.

If you’re an investor, this works best if you can get it closer to the old $85–90K range, budget $60–80K for a full systems/finish rehab, and aim for an after-repair value around $200–230K by modernizing kitchens/baths, finishing the attic for extra sqft, and possibly converting the upper garage to a small rental studio. If you’re the current owner, focus on: restoring heat, basic plumbing/electrical safety, and finishing the downstairs bath to make it financeable; then do clean-out, paint, floors, and simple curb appeal so a retail buyer can see the Victorian charm without being scared off by big-ticket repairs.