This 3-bed, 1-bath single-family home in Pleasant Valley, NY, with 1,520 sqft, is poised for solid rental performance. Based on comps and local averages, monthly rent ranges from $2,100 to $2,600, with most similar properties fetching roughly $2,200–$2,300[1]. Annual potential gross revenue is $25K–$31K. With steady demand and rising home values, payback period (ignoring financing costs) falls between 20–25 years. The large lot (13.5 acres) and classic ranch style add cachet, though only one bath may limit appeal for larger households.

To boost rental income, consider adding a second bathroom or updating finishes—these investments often yield higher rents and reduce vacancy. If selling, highlight acreage, proximity to schools, and the property’s solid rental track record. Modernizing the kitchen or adding outdoor amenities (think patio or fencing) could help the property stand out in this competitive market. Sometimes, small upgrades make a major difference in tenant quality—and rent.