The Flip Potential of
57 Stoll St Port Jervis, NY is medium.

Looking at 57 Stoll St, you've got a solid 4-bed, 2-bath Colonial with 2,004 sqft in Port Jervis. The current valuation is around $376K. Recent comps for similar 4-5 bed homes in the area are hitting average sold prices between $370K and $435K, with price per sqft ranging from $176 to $216. The Port Jervis market is somewhat competitive, with median sale prices around $294K–$312K and homes selling 3–4% below asking after about 1-2 months on market. The comps show this property is priced above the median, but it’s also bigger than most nearby homes.

If you're thinking of flipping, the upside is limited; the spread between current value and top comps (about $425K) isn’t huge, especially after factoring in closing and renovation costs. For a homeowner looking to sell, focus on curb appeal and some light interior updates—fresh paint, landscaping, and staging can help make it stand out in a competitive market. Port Jervis is a seller’s market right now, so smart, cost-effective improvements could attract solid offers.