Frontflip
Deals
My Reports
Get the iOS app
Invite
Settings
Login / Sign up
Deals
My Reports
1156 Old Ford Road, New Paltz Investment Report: Flip & Rental Analysis · Frontflip
46
Value up to $1.56M, 2 comps deep
Updated 10 days ago • 1 new comp
Your Investment Paths
Turnkey Rental
Renting 1156 Old Ford Road offers solid income potential. Market analysis suggests a monthly rental range between $6,169 and $7,694. With an estimated yield of 2.38%, this property serves as a stable, long-term wealth builder. Annual appreciation of approximately $60,694 further strengthens the investment outlook. While the yield is modest, the combination of premium rental income and consistent market growth makes this a compelling opportunity for a savvy investor.
More about this home
Neighborhood Assessment
This stretch of Old Ford Rd gives you that classic Hudson Valley feel: woods, river, mountain views, and real privacy, but you’re still just a short drive to New Paltz village, SUNY New Paltz, and the Wallkill Valley Rail Trail. Schools in the district are well-rated, which quietly supports long‑term demand. Nearby homes are mostly smaller and older, so this 5.1K sqft contemporary with pool, tennis, and solar sits at the top of the local stack. It’s a lifestyle and destination property more than a walk-to-everything spot, playing to second-home, retreat, and high-end rental demand rather than everyday commuters.
Market Activity
+ Ask a question in the app
Rental Income
$83K
Yield
2.4%
Appreciation
$61K
Year 1 Estimates
Fix-and-Flip
Modernizing your home creates a fresh, inviting environment that resonates with buyers. While current market trends prioritize the inherent scale of your 5,156 square foot residence, tasteful updates significantly elevate the lifestyle experience and daily comfort. Updating elevates your property’s appeal, helping it shine in a competitive market. Even when price gains vary, these improvements enhance long-term value, ensuring your home remains a stylish, highly desirable sanctuary for years to come.
Comps
0
Buy-Rehab-Rent
This luxury property shows limited BRR potential due to a lack of renovation-specific sales data. While the market baseline suggests a valuation near 1.3 million, the current lack of exit comparables makes value-add projections speculative. Rental projections are more promising, with monthly income potentially reaching 6,169 dollars. However, the high purchase price and stagnant appreciation suggest a cautious approach is necessary before committing capital to this significant, high-end residential asset.
Estimated value
$3.5M
$2.6M over comp median
Comparative Market Analysis
$550K – $1.5M
~259 days to sell
Based on 6 comps