Based on comps and current market data, this 4-bed, 3-bath, 2,279 sqft single-family in Hyattsville should command $3,000–$3,715/month, with the upper range achievable if the basement is rented separately or the property is upgraded. That’s $36K–$44.6K in projected annual revenue. Assuming minimal vacancy and stable pricing, the payback period (price ÷ annual rent) falls between 8.75 and 10.8 years—solid for the area. Hyattsville rents are rising, though the market is competitive, and demand for larger homes with flex layouts is strong. The basement’s private entrance, multiple living zones, garage, and fenced yard boost rental appeal. The main challenge is the property’s as-is condition, which could limit initial rent unless improvements are made.

To maximize rental value, focus on modernizing kitchens and baths, fresh paint, and sprucing up curb appeal—these bring the best ROI. Upgrading the basement suite into a legal accessory dwelling could further increase rent or attract multi-generational tenants. If selling, consider marketing to both owner-occupants and investors, highlighting the flexible layout and income potential. Staging the basement as a rentable unit may help justify a premium listing price.