The estimated rent potential for 769 Railroad St, Windber, PA, is around $1,500/month, which is above the local average but justified by its size (2,700 sqft), 4 bedrooms, and 2.5 baths. This is significantly larger than nearby comps, most of which are under 1,000 sqft and would command much lower rents ($500–$800/month)[1]. At $1,500/month, annual gross revenue is $18K. With recent sale prices near $135K–$159K, the payback period (gross) is roughly 7–9 years, not factoring in expenses or vacancies. Windber’s rental market is cool with high vacancies (21%)[4], but the property’s unique size, acreage, and features like central cooling and an attached garage set it apart.

To maximize rental income, consider light cosmetic upgrades, modernizing kitchens and baths, or adding amenities like in-unit laundry or outdoor entertaining space. Staging for families or remote workers could broaden appeal. If selling, highlight the rare combination of square footage, 4 bedrooms, and nearly 2 acres—features unmatched locally. Given the high vacancy rate, flexible lease terms or pet-friendly policies may help attract quality tenants.