Based on comp data for similar 4–5 bed, 2.5–3 bath homes in this Greenhills section of Cincinnati, a 2,320 sqft single-family with 5 bedrooms commands a monthly rent in the $2,500–$3,500 range. This puts annual rental revenue between $30K and $42K. With a list price of $249K, your estimated payback period (gross rent multiplier) is roughly 6–8 years—quite attractive in today’s market. Cincinnati’s rental demand is robust, with below-average vacancy and rent growth forecast at 3–4% for 2025. Property features like a wooded lot, large eat-in kitchen, and proximity to Winton Woods park are big draws, though the need for renovations may deter some tenants until updates are made.

To maximize rental income, the owner should address cosmetic and functional updates—think flooring, paint, and kitchen refreshes. Highlighting the 5-bedroom layout and outdoor space will attract families and roommate groups. For those considering a sale, marketing as a value-add rental or house-hack opportunity will appeal to investors interested in strong cash flow and neighborhood appreciation. Don’t underestimate curb appeal and minor upgrades, as these go a long way in a competitive Cincinnati market.