The rent potential for 812 Hayley Cir, Winter Garden, FL, is strong, with a projected range of $2,800 to $3,200 per month based on current market comps and the property's size (2,260 sqft, 4 beds, 3 baths). This equates to an annual gross revenue of roughly $33.6K to $38.4K. With a recent sale price of $449K, your payback period (gross) falls between 11.7 and 13.4 years. The local market remains hot, driven by demand, family-friendly amenities, and proximity to Orlando attractions[3][5]. Features such as a fenced yard, new appliances, above-ground pool, and outdoor kitchen boost rental appeal, though the two-story layout and above-ground (not inground) pool could limit some tenant demand.
To maximize rental income, consider minor upgrades focused on curb appeal and interior finishes, and keep the outdoor amenities well-maintained. Marketing the home’s family-friendly features and proximity to top-rated schools can help attract higher-paying tenants. If contemplating a sale, highlight the property’s size, modern appliances, and outdoor entertainment spaces—these are differentiators in this market. Competitive pricing, given strong local demand, will help secure a quick lease or sale.